Three unbranded iPhones in different sizes and colors beside an open gift box on a cream kitchen counter, ready to be chosen as a gift

Best iPhone Model to Buy as a Gift: Which iPhone Should You Pick for Them?

Updated on | 17 mins read

Six iPhones sit on Apple's iPhone page right now, and the person you're buying for will only ever carry one of them. You may not know how full their storage is, how old their current phone is, or whether they'd trade a better camera for a lighter pocket.

The best iPhone model for most gifts is the iPhone 17 with 256GB of storage. It has a 6.3-inch screen with a 120Hz refresh rate, Apple's A19 chip, and GSMArena's comparison puts it at up to 30 hours of video playback. Choose the iPhone 17e for a first-time or older user, an iPhone 18 Pro or 18 Pro Max for a serious photographer, and a Plug Certified iPhone 16 when you want to spend less.

The lineup, storage options and update list in this guide come from Apple's own pages (checked Oct. 27, 2026). The display, chip, camera and battery figures come from outside reviews, mainly GSMArena's comparison. This is not hands-on testing by Plug.

The Short Answer: One Pick per Kind of Recipient

Start with who is opening the box, because the right iPhone for a teenager is rarely the right one for a grandparent. Here is how the picks line up:

Who it's for The pick Why it fits To spend less
First-time user or an older parent iPhone 17e Macworld recommends it for seniors and first-time users: a current chip and long battery life without the Pro extras Plug Certified iPhone 16
A younger kid iPhone 17e Macworld's pick for younger kids as well Plug Certified iPhone 16
An older teen iPhone 17 Better cameras and a smoother display, Macworld's pick for older teens Plug Certified iPhone 16
Someone still on an iPhone 11 or 12 iPhone 17 The reviewers' "most people" pick, and a big step up from a phone that old Plug Certified iPhone 16 or iPhone 15 Pro
A photographer or heavy user iPhone 18 Pro or 18 Pro Max Trusted Reviews names the 18 Pro Max the best iPhone overall and calls the 18 Pro its one-handed pick Plug Certified iPhone 17 Pro
Someone who wants thin and light iPhone Air Thin and light, for someone who values pocket feel over extras Plug Certified iPhone 17
You really don't know iPhone 17, 256GB A safe middle on screen, camera, battery and storage Plug Certified iPhone 16, 256GB

Apple's own lineup right now, per its iPhone page, is the iPhone Duo, iPhone 18 Pro, iPhone Air, iPhone 17, iPhone 17e and iPhone 16. Earlier models, like the iPhone 17 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro, are no longer on that list, which is where Plug Certified phones come in.

There are no prices in the table because Plug's prices move with the market. Check the live listing for each model, and whether it's in stock, on the day you buy. If you're still deciding whether an iPhone works as a present at all, buying an iPhone as a gift for someone covers the basics.

Start With What They Have Now

The age of the phone they carry today decides most of this, so find out what it is before you pick anything. On their iPhone, go to Settings > General > About and read the line called Model Name. If asking would spoil the surprise, a partner, roommate or sibling can check it for you.

Once you know the model, here is the rule of thumb reviewers at Tom's Guide and Wirecutter use:

  • iPhone 11 or older: An upgrade is usually worth it. The iPhone 11 is the oldest standard model on Apple's iOS 27 list, and Macworld counts the 11 and 12 as nearing the end of their practical software life.
  • iPhone 12: Optional. It makes sense if their battery fades by mid-afternoon or the camera is holding them back.
  • iPhone 13: Usually a skip, unless battery or camera limits are a daily annoyance.
  • iPhone 14 or newer: The new phone is a treat, not a rescue. Pick on what they'd enjoy, like a bigger screen or a better camera.

An iPhone 13 that still gets through the day is a bit like a car with plenty of miles left on it. Replacing it is nice. Replacing an iPhone 11 with a tired battery is the gift they'll feel every single day.

What if you can't find out at all? Then the iPhone 17 with 256GB is the pick, because it's a solid step up from almost anything older and doesn't push them into Pro territory they may not use.

How They Use It Decides the Model

For most people, the standard iPhone 17 covers everything they do; the other models earn their place only when one need stands out. Here is what each one does for the person holding it:

  • iPhone 17 (the standard iPhone): A 6.3-inch display with a 120Hz refresh rate, the A19 chip, a 48MP ultrawide camera and an 18MP Center Stage front camera. This means scrolling and games look smoother, wide group shots come out sharper, and video calls look better than on an older phone.
  • iPhone 17e: Macworld describes it as a current chip and long battery life without Pro complexity. Apple sells it in 256GB and 512GB. This means a simple, capable phone for someone who calls, texts, takes photos of the grandkids and wants it to last all day.
  • iPhone Air: Thin and light, with what Apple calls its Fusion camera system. Apple offers it in 256GB, 512GB and 1TB. This means a light pocket feel, for someone who cares more about how the phone carries than about camera extras.
  • iPhone 18 Pro: Built for serious camera work in a size that still fits one hand. This means more control over photos and video for someone who already shoots a lot.
  • iPhone 18 Pro Max: The biggest screen and the longest battery in the lineup, per the reviewers. This means the phone for heavy users: long trips, lots of video, a screen big enough to read on.
  • iPhone 16: Still sold by Apple, with the A18 chip and a 6.1-inch 60Hz display. This means a dependable phone for someone who won't notice the smoother screen on the 17.

A quick way to read the Pro question: if their camera roll is mostly receipts, pets and screenshots, the standard model is plenty. If they shoot video on purpose, edit photos, or talk about lenses, the Pro models are worth a look.

Size matters more for a gift than most specs do. The Air and the Pro Max feel very different in the hand, so if you know they love small phones, lean toward the iPhone 17 or 18 Pro.

How Much Storage to Pick: 256GB Is the Safe Default

Pick 256GB when you don't know their habits. Macworld calls it the sweet spot, and Engadget's breakdown lands in the same place for most people.

Here is when to go up or down:

  • 128GB: Only for a light user who keeps photos in iCloud and doesn't download much. This mostly comes up on earlier models, since Apple lists the iPhone Air and iPhone 17e starting at 256GB.
  • 256GB: The default for a gift. Room for years of photos, apps and messages without constant clean-up.
  • 512GB or more: For someone who shoots a lot of video, plays big games or creates content.

Storage is like the size of a closet in a new apartment. You can't add space later, so you buy for the wardrobe they'll have in three years, not the one they have now.

If you can borrow their phone for a moment, Settings > General > iPhone Storage shows how much they're using today. If they're near the top of a 128GB phone, 256GB is the floor.

How Long It Will Keep Getting Updates

Apple doesn't publish a fixed support period for iOS, its operating system, but major upgrades have usually run about five to seven years, according to Macworld. That's a typical range, not a promise from Apple.

Apple's iOS 27 compatibility list is the clearest guide on the day you buy. It covers the iPhone 11 and newer, plus the iPhone SE (2nd and 3rd generation). This means any model from the iPhone 16, 17 or 18 lines sits comfortably on today's list, while an iPhone 11 or 12 is close to the bottom of it.

For a gift, that tilts the pick toward newer models. A phone that drops off the list a year after they unwrap it is a phone they'll be replacing soon.

iPhone 17 vs iPhone 16: Is the Older One Enough?

For most people the iPhone 17 is the better gift, and the iPhone 16 is enough for someone who uses their phone for the basics. Here are the differences that matter, from GSMArena, CNET and Tom's Guide:

iPhone 17 iPhone 16
Display 6.3-inch, 120Hz 6.1-inch, 60Hz
Chip A19 A18
Ultrawide camera 48MP 12MP
Front camera 18MP Center Stage 12MP
Video playback (GSMArena's comparison) Up to 30 hours Up to 22 hours

The screen is the change people notice first. At 120Hz the display refreshes twice as often as the iPhone 16's, so scrolling through messages or social feeds looks noticeably smoother.

The battery figures come from GSMArena's comparison. Independent battery tests of the two phones were mixed, so treat the eight-hour gap as a rating rather than a guaranteed day-to-day difference.

The iPhone 16 suits someone coming from an older phone who has never used a 120Hz screen, mostly takes photos with the main camera, and cares more about the price than the spec sheet. Both phones are on Apple's iOS 27 list.

Older iPhones Worth Giving, and the Ones to Pass On

The strongest older picks are the iPhone 16 and the iPhone 15 Pro, which Macworld names as the best value among earlier models. Past those two, check the features and the update list before you commit.

Here is how the earlier models stack up as gifts:

  • iPhone 17 Pro: Last year's Pro. This means a photographer stays in the Pro line, as a Plug Certified phone at a lower price than an 18 Pro.
  • iPhone 16: Still sold new by Apple, which tells you it's current enough to give. Refurbished iPhone 16 Pro vs. standard compares the two versions. As a Plug Certified phone, it's the value pick for nearly every kind of recipient in the table above.
  • iPhone 15 Pro: An older Pro model. A good fit for the teen or adult who wants one of the Pro models without paying Pro prices.
  • iPhone 14 Pro: Macworld notes it doesn't run Apple Intelligence. If the person you're buying for wants Apple's newest features, check Apple's own list of supported models before choosing this one. If color matters to them, there is also a guide to the iPhone 14 in blue.
  • iPhone 11 and 12: Still on Apple's iOS 27 list, but at the bottom of it. As a gift, they're the ones most likely to need replacing soon.

A year-old Pro often makes more sense than a brand-new base model for someone who cares about the camera. A brand-new base model often makes more sense than a three-year-old Pro for someone who cares about updates.

A Sensible Budget: Where a Plug Certified iPhone Fits

Set the budget by the model first, then decide between new and Plug Certified. If the word "refurbished" is unfamiliar, what refurbished means explains it, and cheap unlocked iPhones shows what lower budgets can buy. A Plug Certified phone is the way to give a newer, better model than the same money buys new.

Wirecutter's reasoning in its iPhone guide points the same way: a year-old model is usually the better value. At Plug, that's the whole idea. You choose the model, and a Plug Certified one comes in at up to 70% off retail.

Here is what a Plug Certified gift arrives with:

  • Checked before it ships: Each phone goes through Plug's 90+ Point Inspection on its way to you.
  • A battery at 80% or higher: Battery health starts at 80% or above, so at least four-fifths of the battery's original capacity is still there on day one.
  • Unlocked: Their carrier doesn't matter, because unlocked phones work with whatever plan they already pay for.
  • Plug's 12-Month Warranty: A year of cover for hardware and software faults under normal use, though not for accidental damage.
  • Condition grades describe looks only: Good, Great and Excellent tell you about the outside. If the gift box matters, Excellent is the grade to choose for appearance; the phone inside is tested the same way at every grade.

One distinction helps when you compare listings. A phone that runs flat by dinner has a battery life problem; how much capacity the battery has kept since it was new is battery health, and that's the number Plug's 80% line is about.

Here is how to stretch a fixed budget without short-changing them:

  • Keep the storage, step down a generation: A Plug Certified iPhone 16 at 256GB, when it's in stock, tends to serve a gift better than a newer model squeezed to the smallest size.
  • Step down within the Pro line: For the photographer, a Plug Certified iPhone 17 Pro or iPhone 15 Pro, when in stock, keeps them in the Pro line at a lower price than an iPhone 18 Pro.
  • Spread the cost: Afterpay and Affirm are available at checkout.

Every device carries our name and our warranty. That's our promise. Outside reviewers have noticed too: Wirecutter, The New York Times' product-review site, named Plug the "Best Experience" in its guide to the best place to buy used iPhones.

Buying from a private seller works differently, and the best place to buy a refurbished iPhone compares the options. The phone comes as-is: usually no warranty, no inspection you can see, and a battery that is whatever it shows when you check.

If You Get It Wrong: Returns and Setup

A gift pick can miss, and that's fixable. Your Plug order comes with 30-day returns. The full terms sit on Plug's guarantee page, so check the window against the day you plan to hand it over. Our guide on whether you can return an iPhone gift covers the wider question.

If you buy from anyone other than a store, make sure Activation Lock is off before you pay. Activation Lock ties a phone to its owner's Apple Account, so ask the seller to turn it off while you watch.

Before you wrap it, sort out the extras:

  • Get the case right: Cases are usually cut for one model, so check that the case names the exact phone. Buy it once the phone is settled, and see iPhone gift accessories for ideas.
  • Give more than the phone: If you'd like the box to hold a little extra, Plug Packs and the Starter Pack come ready-made.

Once it's unwrapped, the person setting it up usually signs in with their own Apple Account and can move their data across from their old phone. Plug has a step-by-step guide to setting up an iPhone you got as a gift, which is worth passing along with the box.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I get the iPhone 17 or 16?

Get the 17 unless the price gap is wide. Reviewers' rule of thumb is that the iPhone 16 makes sense when it costs $100 to $200 less than the 17 and the person won't miss the smoother screen. Below that gap, the 17's 120Hz display and newer cameras are worth the difference for a phone they'll keep for years.

Is the new iPhone worth the upgrade?

No, not if their phone is only a year or two old. Reviewers suggest upgrading on a needs-based cycle of about two to four years, driven by a fading battery, a camera that holds them back, or an iPhone dropping off Apple's update list, rather than by a new model's release.

Which iPhone is the easiest to use?

The setup matters as much as the model. Apple's accessibility settings can make a current iPhone simpler to use for someone who finds the standard layout busy. For a child's first phone, Wirecutter's guide to first phones for kids covers Screen Time, Apple's setting for limits on a child's phone, which is worth turning on before you hand it over.

How long will an iPhone keep getting updates?

Security updates tend to last longer than major iOS upgrades. Macworld puts security coverage at commonly seven to eight years, beyond the usual five to seven for new iOS versions. Apple's security releases page lists which models each update covers, so it's the place to check how an older iPhone is doing today.

What does 80% battery health mean on a Plug Certified phone?

It means the battery holds at least 80% of the charge it held new. You can see it as Maximum Capacity in Settings > Battery > Battery Health & Charging. For context, Apple designs iPhone 15 models to keep 80% at 1,000 complete charge cycles under ideal conditions, and iPhone 14 and earlier at 500.

Back to blog